Jay Rustenholtz The "CaringCarGuy" at Zeigler Ford of Plainwell in Kalamazoo, MI

How may I best serve you?

My name is Jay Rustenholtz and they call me the #CaringCarGuy because rather then just selling a car I believe in diving in deeper to creating lasting relationships with my clients! I’m putting God and our community first! My goal is to provide the best car buying experience in Kalamazoo by respecting people’s time and providing all the information upfront. My 100% transparent process will ensure you have the best car buying experience in Kalamazoo! If you or someone you know is looking for the best car buying experience in Kalamazoo, call me Jay Rustenholtz the #CaringCarGuy today. My cell phone number is 269-215-0340. To see all of our inventory or to book your VIP appointment visit www.caringcarguy.com I look forward to being at your service and providing the best car buying experience in Kalamazoo!

Popular New Vehicles kalamazoo, MI

Used Vehicle Specials kalamazoo, MI

Looking to Buy a Car?

Now is a great time to buy a new or used car, truck, minivan or SUV! Zeigler Ford of Plainwell provides the largest selection in the Kalamazoo, MI area. Not seeing the car or truck you want to purchase? Click here to let me know and I'll do my best to find it.


Sell Us Your Car

We want your car! Our experts will pay you fair market value for your preowned vehicle no matter what condition it's in. Contact me to schedule an evaluation of your vehicle.


Thousands of Customers Behind our Success

The community has spoken: Zeigler Ford of Plainwell and yours truly go above and beyond to provide an exceptional customer experience! View my customer reviews and see why people come back again to me at Zeigler Ford of Plainwell in Kalamazoo, MI.


Our E-books are packed with great information.

Download one now!

See all E-books

Want to Earn ?

Learn More


Cars For Sale




Satisfied Customers


Blog Posts


Social Interactions